Biography
of Charles Watt Moorman
The Handbook of Texas Online.
http://www.tsha.utexas.edu/handbook/online/articles/view/MM/fmo39.html
by Michael Moorman Fricke
MOORMAN, CHARLES WATT
(ca. 1817-1850). Watt Moorman, a leader in the Regulator-Moderator War, son of
Charles Hancock and Sophia (Maghee) Moorman, was born in Huntsville, Alabama,
around 1817. His parents settled in Tuscaloosa, Alabama, and Columbus,
Mississippi, before being driven to Texas by the Panic of 1837.
The Moormans, including
Watt's three brothers and three sisters, settled in northwest Shelby County
(later a part of Panola County). In 1839 Texas was in turmoil. Most of the new
arrivals were from states steeped in traditional legal recourse and its
protection, but an element in Texas was engaged in producing fraudulent land
certificates, slave theft, and other unlawful activities.
The oldest settlers were
unwilling or unable to control these activities. The new decided if the law
wouldn't, they would, and banded themselves together as "Regulators"
(i.e., vigilantes) dedicated to driving the lawless from Shelby County. This
group was organized by Charles W. Jackson.
Jackson was murdered from ambush, in retaliation for burning the homes of
those the Regulators considered the worst and for killing Joe Goodbread, an
alleged land pirate. Jackson was warning the world about fraudulent headright
certificates (land scrip) being issued by many counties.
Goodbread warned Jackson, the result being Goodbread's death.
The murder of Jackson joined
the issue and began the bloodiest feud in Texas history. Moorman replaced
Jackson as head Regulator, and Ed Merchant organized the opposition under the
name Moderators. Moorman, a natural leader, claimed the loyalty of the best
citizens. Some allege he was a forger from Columbus, Mississippi, who had to
come to Texas, though no record of his supposed crimes exists in the official
court records of Columbus, Mississippi. When he moved to Texas in 1839 he
brought his whole family, a fact that suggests he was no fugitive.
Moorman's Regulators
captured the McFadden brothers, three of Jackson's killers, all Moderators. An
irregular trial was held before most of the Shelbyville townspeople in October
1841. The accused confessed. Bill and Bailey McFadden were hanged, and a younger
McFadden boy was released. Most of the county concurred that the victims not
only killed Jackson but an innocent citizen in his company. Moorman was a hero,
but not for long. The Regulators controlled Shelbyville, where he became a
virtual dictator. Men were killed on both sides, mostly from ambush. Without any
protection, citizens were terrified.
James F. Cravens organized a
group of "Reformers," which a few Moderators joined; but the worst
were denied, including John M. Bradley.
On July 24, 1844, a peace
treaty was signed by Moorman and Cravens. Moorman married Helen Mar Daggett in
early 1844, ignoring the objections of her family. Her brother, Eph.
Daggett, a Regulator, described Moorman:
“Watt could shoot straighter than any man I ever saw. He was a good
scholar, wrote poetry that was real funny, and he had a comical laugh. He would
not confine himself to any kind of business, was the ideal of his father and
mother, played billiards and ten pins, bruised fellows' heads with billiard
cues, rode his friends' horses, spent their money and wore their clothes. He
gave away his own clothes if had more than his share, had the most respectable
men for his friends, and anything he wanted that they had was at his service.
Moorman was usually armed with a Bowie knife and a pair of pistols. He
carried a heavy stick to cane his minor enemies and, like Robin Hood, carried a
hunting horn on his saddle.”
The peace treaty
acknowledged that, "John M. Bradley had seduced many of the respectable
citizens with false allegations about the Regulators." Bradley was
apparently not a party to the treaty; Moorman killed him at a revival in San
Augustine. Bradley had threatened Moorman's life and evidently was involved in
an ambush in which Moorman was shot in the hip.
The feud immediately
resumed, and eventually involved hundreds of men from Harrison County and other
East Texas counties. Even Helen Mar Moorman was involved as a spy. The
Regulators, in a foolish attempt to weaken the Moderators, posted the names of
their best citizens, warning them to leave Shelby County or die. This
highhandedness resulted in dissention, for which Moorman was blamed. The average
citizen now considered him a villain.
When Sam Houston's militia
stopped the war in August 1844, the troops arrested Moorman and jailed him in
San Augustine, but released him on his personal bond several days later. He was
tried in San Augustine for the murder of Bradley, but was acquitted. A new peace
treaty was signed by Regulators M. T. Johnson and John McNairy and Moderators
James Truitt and John Dial.
Watt and Helen had no peace, however. The
Moderators watched them continuously. Both were afraid to leave home after dark,
convinced the Moderators would kill them. They had a daughter in 1845 and were
eventually divorced. Moorman was shot in the back by Dr. Robert Burns in
Logansport, Louisiana, on February 14, 1850. He was probably buried in the
family cemetery on his father's 640 acre-headright in southwest Panola County.
His father was the administrator of Watt's estate. Burns was acquitted, partly
because of Moorman's reputation. Jenny, Watt's daughter, delivered the original
peace treaty to Mary Daggett Lake in March 1926. It is in the Mary Daggett Lake
Papers in the Fort Worth Public Library. Though some considered Moorman a
villain, the Moorman family was naming people after him as recently as 1925.
BIBLIOGRAPHY:
George L. Crocket, Two Centuries in East Texas (Dallas: Southwest, 1932; facsimile reprod. 1962).
C. L. Douglas, Famous Texas Feuds (Dallas: Turner, 1936).
John Warren Love, The Regulator-Moderator Movement in Shelby County, Texas (M.A. thesis, University of Texas, 1936).
John W. Middleton, History of the Regulators and the Moderators (Fort Worth: Loving, 1883).
Oran M. Roberts, "The Shelby War, or the Regulators and the Moderators," Texas Magazine, August 1897.